Best Practices Guide For Class Actions in Ontario  

Introduction

These best practices for class actions in Ontario were prepared by the Class Actions Bench-Bar Liaison Committee. The purpose of this guide is to assist counsel in preparing for steps in class proceedings. These best practices should be read together with Part III of the Consolidated Civil Provincial Practice Direction.

Part A – Case Management of Class Actions

  1. Early case management is essential to address initial steps in the proceeding such as setting the timetable for the certification motion and any other anticipated motions, dealing with carriage issues or other issues which affect the timely advancement of the matter.
  2. As soon as possible after the commencement of the claim, the parties should consult with one another about the issues described below. Counsel for the parties are to make best efforts to resolve all issues on their own, in particular those relating to scheduling and timetabling, before seeking the assistance of the case management judge. Where agreement cannot be reached, the party seeking to schedule a case management conference should write to the case management judge or trial co-ordinator as applicable, to schedule a case conference. With respect to scheduling and timetabling issues, where agreement is reached, counsel should provide the timetable to the case management judge and seek the court’s endorsement.
  3. Counsel are expected to keep the court apprised of major developments in the case, including if there is to be a suspension of the timetable.
  4. In advance of case management conferences (prior to, and post-certification), a brief summary of the status of the case, issues in dispute and respective positions of the parties should be prepared and provided to the case management judge. This agenda and information should be provided to the case management judge at least 2 days prior to the case conference. It should be sent electronically to the case management judge, through the case management judge’s assistant, or as otherwise directed by the court.
  5. The checklist below provides guidance on the issues counsel should consider in preparation for case management conferences prior to and following certification. To the extent possible, counsel should advise the court of the position on the issues described in sections I to IV below, prior to the first case conference. A sample timetable for certification or other motions is also provided.

 Checklist for Case Management prior to the Certification Motion

  1. Status of the proceeding, pleadings, third party claims
    1. Have all parties been served with the originating process?
    2. If not, when will that be completed?
    3. Have any of the Defendants delivered a Statement of Defence?
    4. Do any of the Defendants seek to postpone delivery of their Defence until after certification?
    5. If so, is that opposed by the Plaintiff(s)?
    6. Have any Third Party Claims been made by any of the Defendants (or are any contemplated)?
      If so:

      1. Have the Third Parties been served?
      2. Have any of the Third Parties delivered a defence to the Third Party action or the main action? What is the intention regarding timing of Defences and the positions of the parties?
      3. Will the Third Party actions be held in abeyance until after the determination of the common issues or some other step in the class action? and
      4. Will there be any involvement by the Third Parties in the class action? If so, to what extent?
    1. Are any amendments to pleadings presently contemplated?
      If so:

      1. What is the nature of the proposed amendments?
      2. Is leave of the court required?
      3. By what date will any anticipated amendments be completed?
      4. Do any of the anticipated amendments necessitate material changes to the pleadings of the other affected parties?
  1. Related proceedings
    1. Are there any other class proceedings in Canada with respect to the same matters in issue in this proposed class proceeding? If so, in which jurisdictions?
    2. If the other proceeding(s) have been commenced in Ontario:
      1. Have counsel in the other proceedings been given notice of this proceeding?
      2. What is the status of the other proceeding(s) (e.g. pre-certification, certification motion scheduled but not yet heard, certified, settled pending court approval etc.)?
      3. Has a different case management judge(s) already been assigned to the other proceeding(s)?
      4. Is a carriage motion necessary? If so, when will it be brought and has a timetable been fixed for the exchange of material and other steps leading up to the carriage motion?
    1. If the other proceeding(s) were commenced in other provinces;
      1. What is the extent of the overlap if any, in the proposed classes in each proceeding?
      2. What is the status of the other proceeding(s) (e.g., pre-certification, certification motion scheduled but not yet heard, certified, settled pending court approval etc.)?
      3. Has a case management judge(s) been assigned in the other proceding(s)?
      4. Has it been agreed or determined that the proceeding in one province is to be the lead proceeding, with the others to await the outcome in that province?
      5. Are stay motions, or carriage motions contemplated in other jurisdictions?
  1. Certification motion
    1. Is certification opposed? If so, for each Defendant, which certification criteria are disputed?
    2. Can the number of disputed issues be reduced, or any facts agreed to
    3. What is the agreed upon or proposed length of the certification motion?
    4. Has a timetable for the exchange of material and other steps leading to the certification schedule been agreed upon? (See sample timetable below)

Sample timetable for certification (or other motions)

  Date proposed by Plaintiff Date proposed by defendant(s) if different Date fixed by the Court
Plaintiff to serve motion materials      
Defendant to serve responding materials
Plaintiff to serve reply materials, if any
Cross- Examinations
Motions arising from cross-examinations
Plaintiff to serve factum
Defendant(s) to serve factum(s)
Plaintiff to serve reply, if any
Hearing Date(s)
  1. Should there be page limits for certification motion facta? If so, what are the page limits?
  1. Other motions to be heard together with, or prior to, the certification motion
    1. As early as possible, the parties should advise if there are any other motions which are contemplated which the party seeks to have determined prior to or at the same time as the certification motion.
      If so;

      1. What motions are contemplated?
      2. Do any of the issues overlap with any aspect of the certification test, or would the court in deciding the motion benefit from the evidence being filed as part of the certification motion?
      3. Has the issue of the sequencing of the other motion(s) been agreed upon (prior to, together with, or following the certification motion)?

Part B – Information to be filed in advance of Motions

  1. Rule 37.10.1 requires a moving party to confer or attempt to confer with the other party and file a motion confirmation form (Form 37B). Among other information, Form 37B requires time estimates for oral argument, a list of materials that the presiding judge will require, and identification of the issues in dispute. This is important information necessary for the proper administration of all motions. However, in the context of motions in class proceedings, it will often assist the court to receive more information than is sometimes submitted in Form 37B. Specifically:
    1. When the parties identify the issues for hearing, they should list each element of the legal test, such as the certification test, and identify which elements are contested and which are not. For those that are contested, if possible, the parties should briefly identify, without argument, the key areas of disagreement. For example, what causes of action are in dispute, if any.
    2. When the parties estimate time for oral submissions, they should estimate how much time will be spent on their main submissions, how much time will be reserved for reply, etc. When different counsel will be making submissions on different issues, the parties should estimate how much time each counsel estimates will be required on each issue.
    3. In cases involving several parties or several counsel, the parties should identify which counsel will make submissions on which issues and whether any counsel are making submissions on behalf of a group of parties, such as sometimes happens when there are multiple defendants in a similar position.
    4. When the parties are identifying counsel and time for oral submissions, they should also identify any counsel in overlapping actions who will be seeking to make submissions and whether and how many unrepresented class members or objectors will be seeking to address the court.
    5. When multiple motions have been scheduled to be heard together (e.g., certification motions heard together with jurisdiction motions, motions to strike, evidentiary motions, etc.), the parties should provide their proposal for how they intend to sequence the multiple motions during their oral submissions.
  2. Unless the case management judge has otherwise directed, parties are encouraged, but not required, to provide this information when filing Form 37B, either on the form itself or in an attached schedule. If the case management judge waives the requirement to file a motion confirmation form, parties are nevertheless encouraged to provide this information no later than three business days before the hearing.

Part C – Use of Compendium

  1. For complex class action motions, such as certification and settlement approval motions, counsel are encouraged to consider preparing a hearing compendium of the key materials to be referred to in argument (fair extracts of documents, transcripts, previous orders, authorities, etc. but not argument) to assist the court during the hearing of the motion.
  2. The Compendium should contain only essential materials for the hearing and should be organized in the order in which they will be referred to in argument.
  3. The hearing compendium should include an index that, in addition to listing the materials, identifies where the materials may be located in the full record.  Hyperlinks to the full record are encouraged where possible. Relevant portions of the compendium should be highlighted or side-barred.
  4. Counsel are encouraged to consult among themselves whether preparation of a joint compendium is practicable and can be submitted.
  5. Parties are encouraged to serve and file their Compendiums and upload them onto Case Center as far as possible in advance of the hearing.

Part D – Case Management Post-Certification

  1. As the case progresses beyond certification, case management is useful to facilitate the resolution of interlocutory disputes, sometimes without a formal motion. For example, the following steps should be considered and addressed:
      1. Notice of certification;
      2. Opt out protocol and timelines;
      3. Discovery;
        1. has a comprehensive discovery plan been agreed to setting out the scope of the issues and documents to be produced, from which custodians, and timelines for delivery?
        2. has an electronic discovery protocol been reached?
        3. oral discovery – have the persons to be examined for discovery been identified and agreed upon, and have the timelines and amount of time reserved for examinations been agreed upon?
        4. what discovery motions are likely or contemplated?
      4. Expert report delivery timeline and any proposed consultation as between the experts;
      5. Mediation (prior to, or following discovery, or both);
      6. Pre-trial(s); and
      7. After the action has been set down for trial, consideration of the assignment of a trial judge well in advance of trial, who can address pre-trial issues which arise in complex and large class actions relating to document admission and trial protocol and any amendment(s) to the common issues, as well as other issues.

Last update: May 27, 2022